Win rates, loss patterns, and pipeline performance across Autotask PSA and HubSpot CRM
Win rates, loss patterns, and pipeline performance across Autotask PSA and HubSpot CRM
The data covers the full scope of Autotask PSA records relevant to this analysis, broken down by the key dimensions your team needs for day-to-day decisions and client reporting.
Who should use this: Sales leads, MSP owners, and account managers tracking pipeline health
How often: Weekly for pipeline reviews, monthly for forecasting, quarterly for strategy
Win rates, loss patterns, and pipeline performance across Autotask PSA and HubSpot CRM
Key metrics at a glance across all 1,465 Autotask opportunities.
EVALUATE
SUMMARIZECOLUMNS(
"Total_Opportunities", COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
"Won", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] IN {"Closed", "Implemented"}),
"Lost", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] = "Lost"),
"Active", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] = "Active"),
"Won_Value", CALCULATE(SUM(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[amount]),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] IN {"Closed", "Implemented"}),
"Lost_Value", CALCULATE(SUM(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[amount]),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] = "Lost"),
"Avg_Days_to_Close", AVERAGEX(
FILTER(BI_Autotask_Opportunities,
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] IN {"Closed", "Implemented"}
&& NOT(ISBLANK(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[closed_date]))),
DATEDIFF(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[create_date],
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[closed_date], DAY))
)
Where deals end up across each stage of the Autotask opportunity pipeline.
Every opportunity follows a path from proposal creation to a final outcome. Here is where deals end up across the entire pipeline.
| Pipeline Stage | Deals | % of Total | Value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proposal Created | 31 | 2.1% | €757,155 |
| Proposal Sent | 46 | 3.1% | €3,059,497 |
| Proposal Read | 2 | 0.1% | €4,838 |
| Signed, Scheduled | 34 | 2.3% | €132,532 |
| Signed, Converted to Project | 190 | 13.0% | €1,970,631 |
| Signed, Converted to Ticket | 596 | 40.7% | €1,817,085 |
| Expired / Stale | 16 | 1.1% | €37,677 |
| Lost (all stages) | 509 | 34.7% | €7,059,324 |
The majority of losses (505 out of 509) happen at the "Proposal Sent" stage, before the client signs. Only 4 deals are lost after signing.
EVALUATE
SUMMARIZECOLUMNS(
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[stage_name],
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name],
"Count", COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
"Total_Value", SUM(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[amount])
)
ORDER BY BI_Autotask_Opportunities[stage_name] ASC
Individual performance of your top 7 sales reps, ranked by deal volume.
Performance varies significantly between sales reps. Tom Baker has the highest win rate at 86.9%, while David Rodriguez sits at 54.2%. The gap points to coaching opportunities.
| Sales Rep | Won | Lost | Win Rate | Revenue Won |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| James Mitchell | 175 | 94 | 65.1% | €727,314 |
| Sarah Chen | 131 | 75 | 63.6% | €963,520 |
| Mike Thompson | 120 | 27 | 81.6% | €383,222 |
| David Rodriguez | 115 | 97 | 54.2% | €145,852 |
| Rachel Kim | 94 | 40 | 70.1% | €367,393 |
| Tom Baker | 53 | 8 | 86.9% | €254,894 |
| Lisa Park | 45 | 21 | 68.2% | €192,376 |
EVALUATE
SUMMARIZECOLUMNS(
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[owner_resource_name],
"Won", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] IN {"Closed", "Implemented"}),
"Lost", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] = "Lost"),
"Total_Value_Won", CALCULATE(SUM(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[amount]),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] IN {"Closed", "Implemented"})
)
ORDER BY [Won] DESC
Why deals fail. Breakdown of 234 opportunities with documented loss reasons.
Excluding test data and blank entries (275 records), there are 234 losses with a documented reason. The single most expensive loss category: "Chose a competitor," accounting for €2,557,849 in lost revenue from just 23 deals.
| Loss Reason | Count | % of Losses | Value Lost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Duplicate opportunity | 67 | 28.6% | €461,683 |
| Don't need the product | 46 | 19.7% | €100,709 |
| Bad timing | 41 | 17.5% | €830,017 |
| Customer not responding | 35 | 15.0% | €189,744 |
| Chose a competitor | 23 | 9.8% | €2,557,849 |
| Too expensive | 14 | 6.0% | €407,468 |
| Not interested | 5 | 2.1% | €6,445 |
| Missing features | 3 | 1.3% | €19,717 |
EVALUATE
SUMMARIZECOLUMNS(
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[loss_reason_name],
"Count", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] = "Lost"),
"Total_Value", CALCULATE(SUM(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[amount]),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] = "Lost")
)
ORDER BY [Count] DESC
What makes clients say yes. Based on 193 deals with recorded win reasons.
Only 193 of 832 won deals have a recorded win reason. Of those, "Like our company" dominates at 67.4%, with €1,386,677 in associated revenue. That tells you brand trust is doing the heavy lifting.
| Win Reason | Count | % of Wins | Revenue |
|---|---|---|---|
| Like our company | 130 | 67.4% | €1,386,677 |
| Love the product | 38 | 19.7% | €512,556 |
| Trust our reputation | 15 | 7.8% | €37,807 |
| Like specific features | 8 | 4.1% | €17,614 |
| See the value | 2 | 1.0% | €5,577 |
76.8% of won deals have no win reason recorded. Improving data hygiene here would sharpen your understanding of what closes deals.
EVALUATE
SUMMARIZECOLUMNS(
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[win_reason_name],
"Count", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS(BI_Autotask_Opportunities),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] IN {"Closed", "Implemented"}),
"Total_Value", CALCULATE(SUM(BI_Autotask_Opportunities[amount]),
BI_Autotask_Opportunities[status_name] IN {"Closed", "Implemented"})
)
ORDER BY [Count] DESC
Top 8 clients ranked by deal volume. Wide variation in how well different accounts convert.
Your top 8 clients by deal volume show a wide spread in conversion rates. Anderson Corp converts at 92.7% while Clearwater Solutions and Henderson & Associates sit below 60%.
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Win Rate | 40.9% |
| Won | 18 ($49,540) |
| Lost | 26 ($131,771) |
| Open | 71 ($173,038) |
EVALUATE ROW("TotalDeals", COUNTROWS('BI_HubSpot_Deals'), "WonDeals", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS('BI_HubSpot_Deals'), 'BI_HubSpot_Deals'[deal_stage] = "closedwon"), "LostDeals", CALCULATE(COUNTROWS('BI_HubSpot_Deals'), 'BI_HubSpot_Deals'[deal_stage] = "closedlost"), "WonAmount", CALCULATE(SUM('BI_HubSpot_Deals'[amount]), 'BI_HubSpot_Deals'[deal_stage] = "closedwon"), "LostAmount", CALCULATE(SUM('BI_HubSpot_Deals'[amount]), 'BI_HubSpot_Deals'[deal_stage] = "closedlost"))
Cross-referencing 115 HubSpot deals with the Autotask pipeline for a complete sales view.
HubSpot tracks 115 deals across the sales pipeline. With 18 closed-won and 26 closed-lost, the current close rate sits at 40.9%. That is lower than the Autotask win rate of 62.0%, which makes sense: HubSpot captures earlier-stage leads that have not yet been qualified into Autotask opportunities.
| Deal Stage | Count | Value |
|---|---|---|
| Appointment Scheduled | 2 | €536 |
| Qualified to Buy | 15 | €59,584 |
| Presentation Scheduled | 9 | €49,765 |
| Decision Maker Bought-In | 25 | €43,337 |
| Contract Sent | 11 | €19,816 |
| Onboarding | 9 | €0 |
| Closed Won | 18 | €49,540 |
| Closed Lost | 26 | €131,771 |
EVALUATE
SUMMARIZECOLUMNS(
BI_HubSpot_Deals[deal_stage],
"Count", COUNTROWS(BI_HubSpot_Deals),
"Total_Value", SUM(BI_HubSpot_Deals[amount])
)
ORDER BY [Count] DESC
Two numbers stand out. First, your 62% win rate on decided deals is solid for an MSP. Industry benchmarks typically land between 40% and 55%, so you are outperforming. Second, the "Proposal Sent" stage is your biggest leak: 505 of 509 total losses happen right there. That means your proposals themselves, or the follow-up cadence after sending, need attention.
The competitor losses deserve a closer look. Just 23 deals, but they account for over 2.5 million in lost revenue. These are high-value opportunities where a competitor beat you on something specific. Understanding those 23 deals in detail could prevent similar losses.
On the positive side, "Like our company" is the top win reason by a wide margin. Clients choose you because of who you are, not just what you sell. That brand equity is difficult for competitors to replicate and it gives your sales team a real advantage in competitive situations.
The rep performance gap is actionable. Tom Baker closes at 86.9% while David Rodriguez sits at 54.2%. Both handle significant deal volume. Pairing them for a few months, letting David shadow Tom's proposal and follow-up process, could lift the team average meaningfully.
HubSpot shows a lower close rate (40.9%) than Autotask (62.0%). This is expected: HubSpot captures leads at an earlier qualification stage. The real metric to watch is how efficiently leads move from HubSpot into qualified Autotask opportunities.
Practical steps based on the data.
99% of all losses happen after a proposal is sent but before signing. Review your proposal templates, pricing structure, and follow-up timing. Consider A/B testing different proposal formats on a subset of deals.
23 deals worth €2,557,849 were lost to competitors. Interview the sales reps involved, review the proposals, and identify patterns. Even winning back 3 or 4 of these per quarter changes your revenue picture.
76.8% of won deals and 30% of lost deals have no reason recorded. Make it a required field at close. Better data means better decisions next quarter.
Tom Baker (86.9%) and David Rodriguez (54.2%) both handle high volume. A mentoring setup could lift David's rate by 10+ points, translating to roughly 10 extra wins per year.
"Like our company" drives 67.4% of documented wins. Invest in customer success stories, case studies, and referral programs. Your reputation is your strongest closing tool.
Win rate measures won deals divided by all decided deals (won + lost). Conversion rate measures won deals divided by all opportunities, including those still active. Your win rate is 62.0% and your conversion rate is 56.8%.
The "Proposal Sent" stage. 505 out of 509 lost deals (99.2%) fail at this point. The proposal either does not land well, the follow-up is too slow, or the client finds a competitor before you close.
MSP industry win rates typically range from 40% to 55%. Your 62.0% win rate on decided deals is above average. Your average close time of 33 days is also competitive, as many MSPs see 45 to 60 day cycles.
HubSpot captures leads at an earlier qualification stage. Many HubSpot deals are still being nurtured and have not yet converted into formal Autotask opportunities. The 40.9% HubSpot close rate reflects this broader funnel.
This report combines Autotask PSA opportunity data (1,465 records) with HubSpot CRM deal data (115 records), processed through Proxuma Power BI with AI-generated analysis via MCP.
Connect Proxuma Power BI to your PSA, RMM, and M365 environment, use an MCP-compatible AI to ask questions, and generate custom reports - in minutes, not days.
See more reports Get started